| Date | W-L | Score | Opponent |
| 12-31-67 | W | 40-07 | Houston (AFL Championship) |
| 01-14-68 | L | 14-33 | Green Bay (SB II in Miami) |
| 12-22-68 | W | 41-06 | Kansas City (AFL Playoff) |
| 12-29-68 | L | 23-27 | at N.Y. Jets (AFL Championship) |
| 12-21-69 | W | 56-07 | Houston(AFL Playoff) |
| 01-04-70 | L | 07-17 | Kansas City (AFL Championship) |
| 12-27-70 | W | 21-14 | Miami(AFC Playoff) |
| 01-03-71 | L | 17-27 | at Baltimore(AFC Championship) |
| 12-23-72 | L | 07-13 | at Pittsburgh (AFL Playoff) |
| 12-22-73 | W | 33-14 | Pittsburgh (AFC Playoff) |
| 12-30-73 | L | 10-27 | at Miami(AFC Championship) |
| 12-21-74 | W | 28-26 | Miami (AFC Playoff) |
| 12-29-74 | L | 13-24 | Pittsburgh (AFC Championship) |
| 12-28-75 | W | 31-28 | Cincinnati (AFC Playoff) |
| 01-04-76 | L | 10-16 | at Pittsburgh (AFC Championship) |
| 12-18-76 | W | 24-21 | New England (AFC Playoff) |
| 12-26-76 | W | 24-07 | Pittsburgh (AFC Championship) |
| 01-09-77 | W | 32-14 | Minnesota (SB XI in Pasadena) |
| 12-24-77 | W | 37-31 | at Baltimore (OT)(AFC Playoff) |
| 01-01-78 | L | 17-20 | at Denver (AFC Championship) |
| 12-28-80 | W | 27-07 | Houston (AFC Wildcard Playoff) |
| 01-04-81 | W | 14-12 | at Cleveland (AFC Playoff) |
| 01-11-81 | W | 34-27 | at San Diego (AFC Championship) |
| 01-25-81 | W | 27-10 | Philadelphia (SB XV in New Orleans) |
| 01-08-83 | W | 27-10 | Cleveland (AFC Playoff, Round 1) |
| 01-15-83 | L | 14-17 | N.Y. Jets (AFC Playoff, Round 2) |
| 12-29-68 | L | 23-27 | at N.Y. Jets (AFL Championship) |
| 01-01-84 | W | 38-10 | Pittsburgh (AFC Playoff) |
| 01-08-84 | W | 30-14 | Seattle (AFC Championship) |
| 01-22-84 | W | 38-09 | Washington (SB XVIII in Tampa) |
| 12-22-84 | L | 07-13 | at Seattle (AFC Wildcard Playoff) |
| 01-05-86 | L | 20-27 | New England (AFC Playoff) |
| 01-13-91 | W | 20-10 | Cincinnati (AFC Playoff) |
| 01-20-91 | L | 03-51 | at Buffalo (AFC Championship) |
| 12-28-91 | L | 06-10 | at Kansas City (AFC Wildcard Playoff) |
| 01-09-94 | W | 42-24 | Denver (AFC Wildcard Playoff) |
| 01-15-94 | L | 23-29 | at Buffalo (AFC Playoff) |
| 01-06-01 | W | 27-00 | Miami (AFC Playoff) |
| 01-14-01 | L | 03-16 | Baltimore (AFC Championship) |
| 01-12-02 | W | 24-38 | N.Y. Jets (AFC Wildcard Playoff) |
| 01-19-02 | L | 13-16 OT | at New England (OT) (AFC Divisional Playoff) |
| 01-12-03 | W | 10-30 | N.Y. Jets(AFC Divisional Playoff) |
| 01-19-03 | W | 24-41 | Tennessee Titans (AFC Championship) |
| 01-26-03 | L | 21-48 | Tampa Bay Buccaneers (SB XXXVII in San Diego) |